New Rochelle Gives Away Millions for Development — But What Are Residents Getting in Return?

IDA imposes a 7% local-hiring mandate while advancing two projects seeking tax breaks — but data shows many residents are placed in jobs paying far below a living wage

New Rochelle’s Industrial Development Agency (IDA) took a significant step toward local hiring at its October 28 meeting. But the vote also exposed a larger problem: the IDA  has spent years subsidizing development without demanding enough in return — and the jobs delivered to residents often aren’t good enough to justify the public investment.

Members of the International Union of Painters and Allied Trades (IUPAT) District Council 9 attended the October IDA meeting.

At the meeting, the IDA amended its Uniform Tax Exemption Policy (UTEP) to require developers receiving benefits to employ New Rochelle residents for at least 7% of construction work hours and 10% of post-construction work hours, with payroll reporting and quarterly monitoring.

The measure passed with one dissenting vote from board member Miguel Ayala, a member of International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW) Local 3. “I appreciate that the local hire work hours requirement went up to 7% but I think that’s still way too low,” Ayala said. He also expressed concern that the revised UTEP provides developers with the opportunity to have the 7% requirement waived.

Dozens of members of the International Union of Painters and Allied Trades (IUPAT) District Council 9 attended the meeting, including many who live in New Rochelle. In order to draw attention to the lack of union work, when asked how many were working in New Rochelle, only two raised their hands.

The IDA also advanced two residential projects: 2 Shearwood Place, a 369-unit market-rate tower seeking a 25-year Payment in Lieu of Taxes (PILOT) plus sales- and mortgage-recording-tax exemptions; and 50 Lockwood Avenue, an 89-unit, 100% affordable senior-housing project seeking a 30-year PILOT.

Public hearings are scheduled for Wednesday, November 18, 2026.

The question for taxpayers is straightforward: What are residents receiving for the tax benefits granted to developers?

The IDA’s New 7% Rule: a Floor, not a Triumph

The IDA deserves credit for making local hiring enforceable. But the number raises questions.

In its 2016 Economic Opportunity and Non-Discrimination Policy (EONDP), the New Rochelle City Council established a 20% local construction-work-hour goal. That goal was never adequately enforced. The IDA adopted the same policy one year later with no way of enforcing it. 

The new IDA policy changes aspiration to obligation — but it establishes a mandatory threshold of only 7%.

In effect, New Rochelle is moving from a 20% goal it could not enforce to a 7% requirement it says it can. The new requirement codifies the de minimis level of local participation already being achieved.

Ayala’s dissent is significant: is 7% ambitious enough to produce meaningful change?

The Shearwood Local Hire Claim Needs Scrutiny

The Shearwood presentation says 15% of construction costs — approximately $23.2 million of the $154.5 million construction budget — will go to New Rochelle local hires.

That is different from the 7% construction-work-hour requirement: one measures costs; the other measures hours.

A dollar-based commitment does not tell taxpayers how many residents will work on the project, for how long or at what wages.

At the November hearing, the developer should be asked to disclose how many New Rochelle residents will work on Shearwood, what they will earn, and how many will be apprentices entering a career rather than temporary workers.

The Missing Metric: Good Jobs

This is where New Rochelle’s economic-development policy falls short.

The city has focused on how many residents are hired. It should also ask what kind of jobs they receive.

A $21-an-hour job and a $40-an-hour union construction job are both technically “jobs.” Economically, they are not equivalent.

A temporary $21-an-hour position without benefits or advancement is not the same as a career in union construction work that provides good pay, health insurance, a pension, training, and a voice at work.

The Commissioner of Development, Adam Salgado, did say that he and the IDA were looking into amending the UTEP to also incentivize union construction. This could help solve the current problem of taxpayer dollars being used to support the creation of poverty wage jobs through the IDA’s PILOTS and better align the IDA with the goals of the City Council’s EONDP.

“We would love to work with the Building Trades, and we started a conversation with the unions,” Salgado said. “There is a premium for using a unionized workforce. You are buying quality, craftsmanship. Over the life of a project, [the premium] is recouped. I don’t think those savings are realized during the lifetime of the PILOTs that we are now giving. … We are looking for a third schedule that incentivizes the signing of a PLA (Project Labor Agreement) so that we can partner with the unions and ensure that it delivers value to New Rochelle…. I think there’s a path forward. We’re not there. We’re not going to give up and I think the conversations need to go on.”

The Bottom Line

New Rochelle’s October 28 IDA vote is being presented as a new era of accountability. Local hiring is finally being converted from an aspirational policy into a mandatory IDA condition with reporting and enforcement provisions.

But the 7% requirement also exposes how low the bar has become.

The City Council voted for 20% of construction hours, and the IDA supported that. Now the IDA is celebrating 7%.

At the same time, First Source data shows residents are being placed in jobs often paying $20 to $25 an hour — well below the estimated Westchester living wage.

Meanwhile, the IDA has distributed more than $131 million in tax exemptions while developers reported only 294 new jobs between 2021 and 2024 — approximately $445,000 in tax exemptions per job.

The question isn’t whether New Rochelle should welcome development. It is whether the IDA should keep writing blank checks without demanding measurable economic advancement.

At the November 18 IDA meeting, taxpayers will have the opportunity to ask that question directly.

The answer should be the number of residents who obtained good jobs, living wages, career opportunities,and lasting economic security from the public investment.

That is the return residents should expect from the tax breaks being given to developers.

You may also like...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *